Skip to content

Building Materials & Insulation · Mistakes to Avoid

Roofing Materials: Mistakes to Avoid When Buying

By the Nest & Yard editorial teamUpdated 2026-08-095 min read

Our pick: the Everbuild Black Jack 904 Roof Felt Adhesive – High Strength – Black – 1 Litre — the best Roofing Materials we tested, from £12.08.

A new roof is a significant investment, and getting it right from the start can save you considerable time and money. When considering roofing materials, it’s easy to overlook crucial details that could lead to problems down the line – things like selecting the correct size roll of felt or failing to factor in the ongoing costs of consumables such as adhesive and nails. This guide looks at common mistakes UK homeowners make when buying roofing materials, highlighting areas where a little extra research can significantly improve your project’s outcome, with examples including options like roof felt adhesives and nail fixings readily available on Amazon UK.

See the full range in Roofing Materials.

Everbuild Black Jack 904 Roof Felt Adhesive – High Strength – Black – 1 Litre
Editor's Choice

#1 Pick

Everbuild Black Jack 904 Roof Felt Adhesive – High Strength – Black – 1 Litre
Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars (3,968)
  • Bitumen Adhesive
  • 1 Litre

£12.08

Pros

  • High-strength bitumen adhesive bonds roofing felt to timber, metal and concrete
  • Also doubles as a chipping adhesive for the final capping layer
  • Thousands of verified reviews back up its reliability for shed and flat roof repairs

Cons

  • Strong solvent smell while curing needs good ventilation
View on Amazon →
Everbuild Black Jack 904 Roof Felt Adhesive - High Strength - Black - 5 Litre
Best Value

#2 Pick

Everbuild Black Jack 904 Roof Felt Adhesive - High Strength - Black - 5 Litre
Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars (3,968)
  • Bitumen Adhesive
  • 5 Litre

£26.49

Pros

  • Larger 5L tin suits bigger flat roof and shed roofing jobs without re-ordering
  • High-strength bitumen adhesive bonds felt to timber, metal and concrete
  • Same trusted formula as the smaller 1L tin, with thousands of verified reviews

Cons

  • Strong solvent smell while curing needs good ventilation
View on Amazon →
Galvanised Roofing Felt Clout Nails 13mm (Pack of 50)
Best Budget

#3 Pick

Galvanised Roofing Felt Clout Nails 13mm (Pack of 50)
Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars (1,256)
  • Galvanised Steel
  • 13mm, Pack of 50

£3.37

Pros

  • Wide clout heads grip roofing felt securely without tearing it
  • Galvanised finish resists rust in exposed outdoor conditions
  • Amazon Choice pick with a strong review track record for the price

Cons

  • Small pack size means larger jobs need several packs
View on Amazon →

Pros

  • Well-known IKO roofing brand with a strong track record on Amazon UK
  • Standard grade mineral felt suits sheds, summerhouses and outbuildings
  • Available in multiple lengths and colours to match the job

Cons

  • Standard grade has a shorter lifespan than premium polyester felts
View on Amazon →

FAQ

I've measured my roof but it seems too small – what should I do?

Before purchasing, double-check your measurements against the manufacturer’s specifications and consider a professional survey to ensure accurate calculations. Many people underestimate the required area, leading to incomplete coverage; factor in overhangs and any complex angles.

Some roofing materials come with extra features I don't need – is it worth paying for them?

Carefully examine each product listing to identify genuinely necessary components and avoid superfluous additions that inflate the price. Prioritise the core elements required for your roof’s structural integrity and weather protection.

I’ve bought a roofing material, but I’m realizing I need more materials than initially thought – what are my options?

Check the retailer's (e.g., Amazon's) standard returns policy regarding unused or partially used materials; however, additional purchases will likely incur extra delivery charges.

What running costs should I factor in besides the material itself?

Don’t forget to budget for essential accessories like battens, fixings (nails, screws), underfelt, and potentially flashing – these are crucial for a weatherproof roof installation.

I'm unsure about the correct type of fixings to use with my chosen roofing material; where can I get advice?

Consult the manufacturer’s technical specifications or seek guidance from a qualified roofing professional before selecting and purchasing fixings to ensure compatibility and proper installation.

Should I buy all my materials at once, or should I purchase them in stages?

It's generally advisable to purchase your core materials – like the tiles or slates – first, then add accessories as you progress through the installation process to avoid overstocking and potential wastage.

What considerations should I have when selecting a roofing material for a south-facing roof?

South-facing roofs experience greater solar heat gain; opt for lighter-coloured materials like white or light grey tiles to reflect sunlight and reduce thermal stress on the roof structure.

I’m buying roofing felt – how much do I need, and what thickness should I choose?

The amount of felt required depends on your roof area; generally, 2mm thick felt is suitable for most applications, but check the manufacturer's recommendations based on your specific needs.

What’s the best way to protect my existing roof during installation?

Use protective sheeting and tarpaulin to cover vulnerable areas of your property – this will prevent damage from falling materials or tools during the roofing work.

How do I find out about the manufacturer's warranty for a particular roofing material?

The manufacturer’s warranty details are typically found within the product description on the retailer’s website (e.g., Amazon UK) and should cover defects in materials or workmanship.

In depth

Measuring your roof accurately is the foundational step in any roofing project, and it’s an area where many homeowners make costly errors. Don't rely solely on visual estimates, particularly for larger roofs. A precise measurement requires a professional surveyor. They’ll account for things you won’t immediately notice – roof pitch variations, dormer windows, chimneys, skylights, or any other protrusions that will impact the amount of material needed. Furthermore, they can accurately calculate the area, which is crucial for determining both the quantity and type of roofing material required. Failing to get a proper survey often leads to buying significantly too much material, resulting in wasted money and potentially complicated storage issues. To rectify this, always commission a professional roof measurement before purchasing anything. Consider it an investment; a small fee now can save you considerable expense and hassle later.

Many people are drawn to roofing materials based purely on their aesthetic appeal – perhaps a particularly striking tile colour or the promise of a certain ‘modern’ look. However, selecting a material solely on appearance without considering its suitability for your property's specific needs is a common mistake. The roof pitch, climate conditions in your area (heavy rainfall, prolonged sun exposure), and even the building’s age all play a significant role in determining which materials will perform best long-term. For instance, slate roofing is beautiful but requires a steeper pitch to shed water effectively; installing it on a low-slope roof would be both expensive and inefficient. Similarly, while composite tiles offer a cost-effective alternative to natural stone, they might not withstand the rigours of high winds or extreme temperatures as reliably. Before committing to a particular material, research its performance characteristics in your region and ensure it’s compatible with your roof structure.

The specification sheets provided by manufacturers often highlight impressive features – perhaps exceptional thermal insulation, enhanced weather resistance, or unique colour blends. However, these specifications frequently relate to the *ideal* conditions of installation and use. Many homeowners are swayed by these claims without fully understanding their relevance to a typical household. For example, some materials boast superior insulation properties when installed with specialist underlays; if you’re using standard felt, the benefits might be significantly reduced. Similarly, claims about ‘self-cleaning’ coatings may only work effectively in consistently dry climates – rainfall will quickly diminish their effect. It's crucial to assess whether the advanced features are genuinely necessary for your situation and to factor in the associated installation costs. Opting for a more straightforward material that meets your basic needs can often be a more sensible and cost-effective approach.

Running costs, including labour, are frequently overlooked when budgeting for a roofing project. The initial purchase price of materials is just one element; the actual expense will be considerably higher if you’re undertaking the work yourself. Even experienced DIYers may struggle with tasks such as slate or tile installation, which require specialist tools and techniques. Furthermore, scaffolding hire, professional insulation, and potentially structural repairs can add substantially to the overall cost. Failing to factor in these additional expenses can lead to serious financial strain. Before making any purchase, obtain detailed quotes from multiple roofing contractors – don't just accept a single price. Ask for a breakdown of costs, including materials, labour, scaffolding, and any necessary preparatory work.

Don’t be swayed by marketing terms that focus solely on the material itself; consider the complete system. Many manufacturers promote their products as ‘complete roofing solutions,’ but these often involve additional components – underlays, fixings, sealants – which can significantly increase the cost. Sometimes, a simpler, more traditional approach using readily available materials and standard fixings provides superior value for money. A thorough understanding of the entire roof system is paramount. Speak to experienced roofing professionals about your requirements and explore different options—a well-designed system will be far more durable and reliable than one solely based on a premium material with unnecessary extras.

When considering roofing materials, particularly for larger areas, it’s easy to fall into the trap of buying ‘just enough’ to cover the visible surface. However, there are minimum coverage requirements mandated by building regulations for many materials – this is to ensure adequate overlap and weatherproofing. Underestimating this requirement can lead to serious problems with water ingress and potential structural damage. Building control officers will scrutinise your work, and non-compliance can result in costly remedial action. Always check the relevant building regulations for your area and consult with a qualified surveyor or roofing contractor to determine the correct minimum coverage requirements for your chosen material and roof pitch.

Finally, be wary of materials that promise unrealistic performance improvements over standard options. Claims about dramatically reduced energy bills due to enhanced insulation, for instance, often require substantial investment in complementary products – high-performance underlays, vapour control layers, and sophisticated ventilation systems. These additional features can quickly erode the cost advantages of the premium material. Focus on selecting a robust, durable material that meets your basic needs and complements your building’s existing structure. Don't chase marginal improvements at the expense of overall value for money and long-term reliability.

The Nest & Yard editorial team

Written and reviewed by our UK-based team of home improvement and gardening writers, who research specs, pricing and customer reviews before every recommendation. Reviewed and updated on 2026-08-09.

How we choose products