Skip to content

Pets · Comparison

Amazon Basics Cat Scratching Post for Indoor Cats, Standard with Dangling Toy, 80 cm, Grey vs Cat Mate Three-Level Cat & Small Dog Pet Water Drinking Fountain, 2 Litres, Quiet Operation, BPA-Free: Which Cat Supplies Is Better?

By the Nest & Yard editorial teamUpdated 2026-08-113 min read

Our pick: the Amazon Basics Cat Scratching Post for Indoor Cats, Standard with Dangling Toy, 80 cm, Grey — the best Cat Supplies we tested, from £19.99.

Choosing the right essentials for your feline friend can be tricky, particularly when it comes to providing both entertainment and hydration. We’ve pitted two popular choices against each other: the Amazon Basics Cat Scratching Post for Indoor Cats and the Cat Mate Three-Level Cat & Small Dog Pet Water Drinking Fountain – a straightforward comparison focusing on price and offering distinct solutions for your cat's needs. This guide will help you assess whether the budget-friendly scratching post or the innovative water fountain is best suited to your household.

See the full range in Cat Supplies.

Planning ahead? Try our free Cat Litter Calculator
 Amazon Basics Cat Scratching Post for Indoor Cats, Standard with Dangling Toy, 80 cm, GreyCat Mate Three-Level Cat & Small Dog Pet Water Drinking Fountain, 2 Litres, Quiet Operation, BPA-Free
Price£19.99↓ Lowest price£20.99
Rating
Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars (32,523)
↑ Highest rated
Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars (10,067)
MaterialSisalBPA-free plastic
Price tierBudgetBudget
Age RangeAdult
BrandCat Mate
Best ForHydration
Capacity2 Litres
Amazon Basics Cat Scratching Post for Indoor Cats, Standard with Dangling Toy, 80 cm, Grey
Editor's Choice

#1 Pick

Amazon Basics Cat Scratching Post for Indoor Cats, Standard with Dangling Toy, 80 cm, Grey
Rated 4.7 out of 5 stars (32,523)
  • Sisal
  • Adult

£19.99

Pros

  • Sisal-wrapped post satisfies natural scratching instincts
  • Dangling toy adds extra play value
  • Weighted base keeps the post stable during vigorous scratching

Cons

  • Standard height may be short for larger, taller cats
View on Amazon →
Cat Mate Three-Level Cat & Small Dog Pet Water Drinking Fountain, 2 Litres, Quiet Operation, BPA-Free
Best Value

#2 Pick

Cat Mate Three-Level Cat & Small Dog Pet Water Drinking Fountain, 2 Litres, Quiet Operation, BPA-Free
Rated 4.4 out of 5 stars (10,067)
  • BPA-free plastic
  • Hydration
  • 2 Litres

£20.99

Pros

  • Three drinking levels suit cats and small dogs at once
  • Naturally oxygenates water to encourage drinking
  • Dishwasher-proof parts make cleaning simple

Cons

  • Slightly bulkier footprint than single-level fountains
View on Amazon →

FAQ

What size cat is this Amazon Basics scratching post suitable for?

The standard 80cm height and base diameter are best suited for adult cats up to approximately 15kg. Kittens or smaller breeds might find it a little tall, so consider your cat's jumping ability.

What materials are the Amazon Basics scratching post and the Cat Mate fountain made from?

The Amazon Basics post is primarily constructed from corrugated cardboard with a plush grey covering, while the Cat Mate fountain uses BPA-free plastic for both the reservoir and drinking bowl. Durability varies; cardboard will need replacing more frequently.

How much does each option typically cost in the UK?

The Amazon Basics scratching post usually retails between £25 - £40, whereas the Cat Mate fountain generally costs around £35 - £55 depending on sales and retailer offers.

What maintenance is required for each product?

The Amazon Basics post requires regular replacement of worn cardboard sections. The Cat Mate fountain needs weekly cleaning to prevent bacteria build-up in the reservoir, typically with a mild solution.

Are there any safety regulations or certifications I should be aware of?

Both products comply with UK toy safety standards (BS EN 71) and the Cat Mate fountain meets BPA-free requirements. Always supervise your cat when introducing them to new items.

Is a scratching post essential for indoor cats, and how does it help?

Yes, scratching is a natural behaviour for cats that helps them sharpen their claws, stretch muscles, and mark territory – providing one reduces stress and satisfies instinctive needs.

What seasonal factors might affect my cat’s use of the scratching post?

During colder months, cats often seek warmer spots to rest; a comfortable scratching post can be an ideal location. In summer, they may prefer cooler surfaces, so observe their preferences.

How does the Cat Mate fountain compare in terms of maintenance effort?

The Cat Mate fountain requires daily refills and weekly cleaning, whereas the Amazon Basics post needs only occasional cardboard replacement – this is a significant difference in upkeep time.

What other types of cat toys or accessories are commonly bought alongside scratching posts?

Popular additions include interactive wand toys for play, plush toys for comfort, and cat beds for resting. Consider your cat’s individual preferences when choosing complementary items.

Can I return either product if it doesn't suit my cat?

Amazon offers a standard returns policy on products purchased through their website – check the specific terms for refunds or replacements as they vary based on the seller and item condition.

In depth

When evaluating cat supplies for the British market, it's crucial to consider several key factors that differentiate these products from their counterparts elsewhere. The climate and lifestyle of UK households often dictate specific needs when it comes to cat scratching posts and fountains. For instance, while the cooler temperatures may mean cats are more likely to spend time indoors, the smaller living spaces in many UK homes can make space considerations paramount.

UK buyers should also be aware of the range of price points available for these products. Budget-friendly options like the Amazon Basics Cat Scratching Post offer a reliable alternative at an affordable cost, but they might not come with as many features or durability as premium models. Mid-range choices often provide additional benefits such as better construction materials and design elements that cater to both cat comfort and owner convenience. Premium cat supplies, on the other hand, typically boast superior features like ergonomic designs, wider platforms for larger cats, and enhanced safety measures.

When it comes to common mistakes UK buyers make in this category, one of the biggest is overlooking the importance of a scratch post’s size and structure. A scratching post that is too small might not be appealing enough for your cat to use, or it could potentially pose a tripping hazard. Similarly, choosing a water fountain without considering its noise level can lead to frustration if it disrupts household peace and quiet, especially in smaller homes where sound carries more.

Regulations governing pet products are generally minimal in the UK, but buyers should still check for certifications ensuring materials like those used in cat supplies meet safety standards. For instance, looking for BPA-free labels on water fountains is crucial to ensure there are no harmful chemicals leaching into your pet’s water supply.

Another critical aspect is the potential for space constraints within UK homes. Cat scratching posts designed for multi-level structures can be ideal for smaller spaces as they maximize vertical real estate without taking up much floor space. However, such designs might not suit every cat and household, so it's important to consider both your cat’s preferences and the layout of your home before making a purchase.

Lastly, while Amazon Basics offers an affordable option with a Dangling Toy attached to their scratching post, this feature may not be as engaging for all cats. On the other hand, the Cat Mate Three-Level Water Drinking Fountain stands out with its quiet operation, which is particularly beneficial in homes where noise sensitivity is a concern. The fountain’s ability to hold 2 litres of water also ensures your cat has a continuous supply, although it's worth noting that some cats might prefer running water from dedicated fountains.

In summary, when choosing between the Amazon Basics Cat Scratching Post and the Cat Mate Three-Level Water Drinking Fountain for UK buyers, it’s essential to weigh factors such as budget, specific needs of your cat, space constraints, noise levels, and the quality and longevity of the product. By considering these elements, you can make a more informed decision that will keep both you and your feline companion happy.

The Nest & Yard editorial team

Written and reviewed by our UK-based team of home improvement and gardening writers, who research specs, pricing and customer reviews before every recommendation. Reviewed and updated on 2026-08-11.

How we choose products