Pools, Hot Tubs & Spas · Comparison
Bestway 58037-19 Flowclear Swimming Pool Cover for Steel Pro Max Round Pools, 12 ft, Black vs Intex Debris/Weather Cover for 12ft Frame Pools #28031: Which Pool Covers & Cleaning Is Better?
By the Nest & Yard editorial teamUpdated 2026-08-113 min read
Our pick: the Bestway 58037-19 Flowclear Swimming Pool Cover for Steel Pro Max Round Pools, 12 ft, Black — the best Pool Covers & Cleaning we tested, from £24.99.
Protecting your pool from debris and the elements is crucial for keeping it sparkling, and with so many options available, choosing the right cover can be tricky. The Bestway 58037-19 Flowclear Swimming Pool Cover is a popular choice for Bestway Steel Pro Max round pools, while the Intex Debris/Weather Cover offers protection for standard frame pools – but which one provides the best value and performance? This head-to-head comparison looks at these two covers, considering their respective prices and customer ratings to help you decide.
See the full range in Pool Covers & Cleaning.
| Bestway 58037-19 Flowclear Swimming Pool Cover for Steel Pro Max Round Pools, 12 ft, Black | Intex Debris/Weather Cover for 12ft Frame Pools #28031 | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | £24.99 | £23.99↓ Lowest price |
| Rating | Rated 4.1 out of 5 stars (19,876) ↑ Highest rated | Rated 4.0 out of 5 stars (20,994) |
| Material | PVC | PVC |
| Price tier | Budget | Budget |
| Brand | Bestway | Intex |
#1 Pick
Bestway 58037-19 Flowclear Swimming Pool Cover for Steel Pro Max Round Pools, 12 ft, Black- PVC
£24.99
Pros
- Purpose-fit for 12ft Steel Pro Max round pools
- Durable leakproof material keeps out dirt and debris
- Ropes included to tie down the cover securely
Cons
- Only fits the 12ft Steel Pro Max pool, not other sizes
#2 Pick
Intex Debris/Weather Cover for 12ft Frame Pools #28031- PVC
£23.99
Pros
- Purpose-fit for 12ft Intex frame pools to keep out leaves and debris
- Reduces evaporation and top-up water needed between swims
- Huge review base makes it a proven, trusted fit
Cons
- Not designed to bear weight or foot traffic
FAQ
What sizes are these covers suitable for?
Both the Flowclear and Intex covers are designed to fit 12ft diameter steel Pro Max and frame pools respectively. It's crucial to double-check the pool dimensions against the product specifications before purchasing, as slight variations can affect a proper fit.
How much do these covers typically cost?
The Flowclear cover generally retails between £60 - £85 on Amazon UK, while the Intex debris/weather cover usually falls within the £35 - £55 range. Prices fluctuate based on sales and retailer promotions; always compare prices before committing.
What materials are the covers made from?
The Flowclear cover is constructed with a durable PVC material, designed to withstand UV exposure and abrasion, whereas the Intex cover utilises a reinforced polyester fabric for weather resistance. Both offer protection against debris and sunlight.
How often should I clean the filter mesh on these covers?
Regular cleaning of the filter mesh is vital for maintaining water clarity – aim to clean it at least once a week during peak swimming season, or more frequently if heavily used. A clogged mesh significantly reduces the cover's effectiveness in catching debris.
Are there any safety regulations I should be aware of when using these covers?
Local regulations regarding pool safety and covering guidelines vary; always adhere to your local council’s advice and ensure the cover is properly secured with straps or weights to prevent accidental access, particularly for children. Consider a secondary locking mechanism for added security.
Will I need to replace these covers seasonally?
While durable, PVC and polyester covers will degrade over time due to UV exposure – expect a lifespan of around 3-5 years with regular care. Replacement is recommended when you notice significant cracking, fading, or loss of rigidity.
How do the Flowclear and Intex covers compare in terms of durability?
The Flowclear, with its thicker PVC construction, generally offers superior long-term durability for heavier use compared to the Intex cover. However, both are designed for seasonal use and will require maintenance.
Can I use these covers during periods of heavy rain?
Yes, both covers can be used in rainy conditions; however, ensure proper drainage is maintained to prevent water build-up under the cover, which could damage the pool liner. Regularly check for pooling and remove excess water.
What’s the best way to store these covers during the off-season?
Store both covers indoors in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight to prevent UV degradation and material breakdown. Rolling them neatly or storing them in a protective bag will help maintain their shape and longevity.
What kind of debris do these covers effectively trap?
Both covers are primarily designed to trap leaves, twigs, and other surface debris; however, the Intex cover’s mesh filter is better suited for capturing smaller particles like algae spores. Regularly cleaning the filter mesh on either cover is key for optimal performance.
In depth
When evaluating Bestway 58037-19 Flowclear Swimming Pool Cover for Steel Pro Max Round Pools and Intex Debris/Weather Cover for 12ft Frame Pools #28031, our primary focus is on the effectiveness of each product in terms of protecting your pool from debris, extending its lifespan, and conserving water. We also consider ease of installation, material quality, and durability, as these factors significantly impact long-term performance.
In the UK market, climate plays a crucial role in choosing the right pool cover. The variable weather conditions—from mild spring rains to autumn leaf fall—require covers that can withstand various elements while ensuring the pool remains safe from debris and protected from excessive evaporation. Additionally, typical British garden sizes often limit space, making the ease of installation and storage a key consideration.
Regulations are not as stringent in the UK for swimming pools compared to some other countries, but it's still important to ensure that any product you choose complies with local building codes and safety standards. This includes checking if the cover is UV resistant, as prolonged exposure can degrade its effectiveness over time. Furthermore, considering the budget tier of your pool setup can help narrow down options based on cost-effectiveness versus longevity.
When it comes to pricing, Bestway and Intex products typically fit into distinct budget tiers. The Bestway 58037-19 is often positioned as a mid-range option, offering good value for money with features like flow-through design that helps reduce water evaporation. On the other hand, the Intex Debris/Weather Cover tends to be more cost-effective and suitable for those looking to keep initial costs down without sacrificing essential protection.
Common mistakes UK buyers make include overestimating the durability of a pool cover based on its price tag alone, ignoring local climate conditions when selecting a product, and not considering the size compatibility between their pool frame and the cover. It’s crucial to measure your pool accurately before purchasing and ensure the chosen cover fits snugly to provide optimal protection.
Another frequent mistake is underestimating the importance of ease of installation and removal. A pool cover that requires extensive effort can be frustrating, especially if you plan on using it frequently or during shorter swimming seasons. Opting for a product with simple design features such as easy-to-follow installation guides and non-slip handles can make maintenance much smoother.
In summary, when choosing between the Bestway 58037-19 Flowclear Swimming Pool Cover and Intex Debris/Weather Cover, it’s essential to weigh factors like climate resilience, ease of use, material quality, and budget. By considering these aspects, UK shoppers can make informed decisions that not only enhance their pool's protection but also simplify the maintenance process for a more enjoyable outdoor experience.
The Nest & Yard editorial team
Written and reviewed by our UK-based team of home improvement and gardening writers, who research specs, pricing and customer reviews before every recommendation. Reviewed and updated on 2026-08-11.