Smart Home & Security · Comparison
Amazon Echo Show 8 (3rd Generation, 2023), HD Smart Touchscreen with Spatial Audio, Smart Home Hub, Charcoal vs Apple HomePod mini, Smart Speaker with Siri, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, App-Controlled, White: Which Smart Speakers & Hubs Is Better?
By the Nest & Yard editorial teamUpdated 2026-08-113 min read
Our pick: the Amazon Echo Show 8 (3rd Generation, 2023), HD Smart Touchscreen with Spatial Audio, Smart Home Hub, Charcoal — the best Smart Speakers & Hubs we tested, from £149.99.
Choosing a smart speaker for your home can feel overwhelming with so many options available. The Amazon Echo Show 8 offers a touchscreen display alongside Alexa’s capabilities, while the Apple HomePod mini focuses purely on audio quality and Siri integration. We’ll be comparing these two popular devices – the Amazon Echo Show 8 and the Apple HomePod mini – to help you decide which best suits your smart home needs and budget.
See the full range in Smart Speakers & Hubs.
| Amazon Echo Show 8 (3rd Generation, 2023), HD Smart Touchscreen with Spatial Audio, Smart Home Hub, Charcoal | Apple HomePod mini, Smart Speaker with Siri, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, App-Controlled, White | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | £149.99↓ Lowest price | Unavailable |
| Rating | Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars (15,000) ↑ Highest rated | Rated 4.6 out of 5 stars (8,900) ↑ Highest rated |
| Brand | Amazon | Apple |
| Price tier | Premium | Mid-range |
| Connectivity | Wi-Fi, Bluetooth & Zigbee | Wi-Fi & Bluetooth |

#1 Pick
Amazon Echo Show 8 (3rd Generation, 2023), HD Smart Touchscreen with Spatial Audio, Smart Home Hub, Charcoal- Wi-Fi, Bluetooth & Zigbee
£149.99
Pros
- Built-in smart home hub supports Zigbee devices directly
- Touchscreen doubles as a video calling and camera viewing display
- Spatial audio noticeably fuller than the Dot
Cons
- Bulkier — needs proper counter or shelf space

#2 Pick
Apple HomePod mini, Smart Speaker with Siri, Wi-Fi and Bluetooth, App-Controlled, White- Wi-Fi & Bluetooth
Currently unavailable
Pros
- Surprisingly rich 360-degree sound for its size
- Deep integration with Apple Home and Siri handoff from iPhone
- Doubles as a Thread border router for Matter devices
Cons
- Siri is less capable than Alexa for third-party smart home skills
FAQ
What's the typical size of the Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) and how does it fit into a room?
The Echo Show 8 measures approximately 16cm tall, 17cm wide, and 9cm deep – ideal for countertops or shelves. It’s large enough to display information clearly but compact enough not to dominate a smaller space; consider the viewing distance when positioning it.
What materials is the Echo Show 8 constructed from?
The device features a premium aluminium frame and a durable, scratch-resistant glass touchscreen. This build quality contributes to its modern aesthetic and provides some protection against everyday bumps and scratches.
How much does the Echo Show 8 (Charcoal) typically cost?
You can generally find the Echo Show 8 (3rd Gen) priced between £149 and £209 on Amazon UK, depending on any current promotions or bundles offered. Be sure to check for deals before purchasing.
How do I clean the touchscreen screen?
Use a soft, slightly damp microfiber cloth to gently wipe down the screen. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive cleaners that could damage the surface.
Are there any safety regulations or warnings associated with using the Echo Show 8?
Amazon recommends keeping the device out of reach of small children and ensuring it's placed on a stable, flat surface to prevent tipping. Always follow local electrical safety guidelines.
How does the Echo Show 8 perform in different lighting conditions?
The HD touchscreen boasts excellent brightness and clarity, performing well in bright rooms but also providing sufficient visibility in dimmer environments – it automatically adjusts its brightness levels.
Can I use the Echo Show 8 outdoors or in damp areas?
While designed for indoor use, you can temporarily place it on a sheltered patio or balcony during dry weather. Avoid prolonged exposure to rain or humidity.
How does the Echo Show 8 compare in price and features to the Apple HomePod mini?
The HomePod mini typically costs around £99, offering focused audio playback but lacking the visual display and smart home hub capabilities of the Echo Show 8. The Echo Show 8's versatility makes it a more comprehensive solution for many users.
What’s the Wi-Fi range like on the Echo Show 8?
The Echo Show 8 supports both 2.4GHz and 5GHz Wi-Fi networks, offering a typical range of up to 10 meters indoors when free from obstructions. Ensure your router is positioned for optimal signal strength.
Does the Echo Show 8 support voice control for smart home devices?
Yes, it’s compatible with a wide range of Zigbee and Z-Wave smart home devices through integration with Amazon Alexa. You can control lights, thermostats, plugs, and more using your voice.
In depth
When evaluating smart speakers and hubs for the UK market, we focus on several key criteria to ensure our recommendations are as relevant and helpful as possible. These include audio quality, ease of use, compatibility with existing home systems, integration with popular voice assistants like Alexa and Siri, battery life, and form factor. Given the typical British climate, which can range from cool summers to chilly winters, we consider how well each device performs in various conditions. In addition, UK homes often have a mix of small flats and larger detached houses, so product size and placement flexibility are crucial factors.
When considering budget, mid-range, and premium tiers for smart speakers and hubs, we see significant differences in price points that reflect the features and build quality of each device. Budget options typically offer basic functionality at an affordable cost, often with limited voice assistant capabilities or fewer smart home integrations. Mid-range devices generally provide a better audio experience, more robust feature sets, and improved compatibility with various smart home systems. Premium tiers cater to those who want top-tier sound quality, extensive features, and seamless integration across multiple platforms.
UK buyers sometimes fall into common pitfalls when choosing smart speakers and hubs. One of the most frequent mistakes is overlooking compatibility with existing devices or services. For example, a user might have invested in an Apple Home ecosystem but opt for an Alexa-powered speaker without considering how well it would integrate with their other Apple products. Another mistake is ignoring the importance of physical space; UK homes often have specific areas where technology needs to be placed, such as kitchens or living rooms, and choosing a device that doesn’t fit well can lead to frustration.
In terms of smart home hubs specifically, we look at how well they handle automation tasks and their ability to connect with other devices. For the Amazon Echo Show 8 (3rd Generation), its spatial audio technology is a standout feature, offering an immersive sound experience in any room size. However, buyers should also consider that this device may not be as portable or as energy-efficient as some of its competitors.
Lastly, while we do not handle returns or warranties directly, it's important to understand the manufacturer’s warranty and Amazon’s standard return terms. For example, the Amazon Echo Show 8 comes with a one-year limited hardware warranty provided by Amazon, which covers defects in materials and workmanship. It's also worth noting that UK buyers can take advantage of Amazon’s flexible returns policy, allowing for easy exchanges or refunds if their device doesn't meet expectations.
By carefully considering these factors, UK shoppers can make informed decisions when choosing the right smart speaker or hub to enhance their home and garden experiences.
The Nest & Yard editorial team
Written and reviewed by our UK-based team of home improvement and gardening writers, who research specs, pricing and customer reviews before every recommendation. Reviewed and updated on 2026-08-11.